Blog

Shopify Metrics to Track for BFCM: Start With Profit

Margin waterfall for one product at full price and at 25% off

The most important Shopify metrics to track for BFCM are measured before the sale starts: your normal-week baseline, profit by product, your breakeven discount, your breakeven ROAS and your MER target. Revenue during Black Friday Cyber Monday tells you what came in. These numbers tell you what will stay.

Most BFCM planning starts with a sales goal and works backward to a discount. This guide works the other way. It starts with your profit data, sets the limits your offers and ad spend have to stay within, and only then looks at what to monitor during and after the sale.

You can work through all seven steps in a few days. With BFCM 2026 starting on November 27, the time to do it is now.

Why analyze profit before BFCM, not just sales after?

Because BFCM changes three things at once, and all three cut profit per order. Discounts lower the price. Ad costs usually peak. Returns arrive weeks after the sales report.

Take a product that sells for $80, with $28 in product cost and $12 in fulfillment and payment fees:

Full price 25% off
Price $80 $60
Gross Profit per order $40 $20
Orders needed for the same Gross Profit 1x 2x
Breakeven ROAS 2.0 3.0

A 25% discount halves the profit on each order and raises the ad return you need just to break even by 50%. A store can double its orders, set a sales record and still keep less profit than a normal week.

If you only check profit after BFCM, the discounts are already given and the ad budget already spent. Checked before, the same numbers decide which products to discount, how deep, and how much you can afford to pay for each order.

Which Shopify metrics should you track for BFCM?

Track ten metrics, grouped by when you use them. Six are planning metrics you set before the sale. The other four tell you during and after BFCM whether the plan is working.

Metric What it measures When to check Decision it drives
Gross Profit Revenue minus product costs, fulfillment and payment fees Before, during, after Which products and offers can afford a discount
Contribution Margin Gross Profit minus marketing and ad spend Before, during, after Whether BFCM actually made money
Breakeven discount The deepest discount a product can take and stay profitable Before Discount depth per product
Breakeven ROAS The ad return needed to cover a product's costs Before Bid limits and when to pause an ad
MER (Marketing Efficiency Ratio) Total revenue divided by total ad spend Before (target), during Whether total ad spend is paying off
aMER (Acquisition MER) New-customer revenue divided by total ad spend Before (target), during Whether ads are winning new customers profitably
Average order value Revenue per order During Whether bundles and thresholds are working
Conversion rate Orders divided by sessions During Spotting checkout problems or weak offers fast
Return rate Share of orders returned, by product After True profit per product after the holidays
Repeat purchase rate Share of BFCM customers who buy again After (30, 60, 90 days) Whether discount-driven customers were worth acquiring

The seven steps below show how to set each planning number from your own store data.

Step 1: Set your normal-week baseline

Your baseline is what a typical week looks like before BFCM. Without it, you cannot tell how much of your BFCM spike was new demand and how much was sales moved from other weeks.

Pull these numbers for an average October week. Use the median of four weeks, not the best one.

Baseline metric Why it matters
Orders per week Shows how big the BFCM lift really was
Average order value Shows whether bundles and offers raised basket size
Conversion rate Gives you a normal range to spot problems during the sale
Gross Profit per week The profit BFCM has to beat to be worth running
Contribution Margin per week The profit left after ad spend in a normal week
Ad spend and MER per week Shows how much ad costs rise during BFCM

Watch for the pre-BFCM dip

Many shoppers hold off in early November to wait for deals. If your sales fall in the two weeks before Black Friday, that is normal, and it is part of the BFCM effect. Compare the whole season, October to December, against last year or your baseline, not just the four days of BFCM.

Market benchmarks help put your baseline in context. See Shopify BFCM Statistics for sales, growth and average cart across Shopify.

Step 2: Map profit by product before choosing offers

Decide your BFCM offers product by product, from margin, not from a sitewide percentage. A product's profit has three layers, and each one tells you something different.

The three profit layers

Layer What it subtracts from revenue What it tells you
Product Gross Profit Product cost How much room the product has before anything else
Gross Profit Product cost, fulfillment, shipping and payment fees How much each order can afford to spend on discounts and ads
Contribution Margin All of the above, plus marketing and ad spend What the product actually earns you

A product can look healthy on Product Gross Profit and still lose money once shipping, fees and ads come out. Use Gross Profit to plan discounts and Contribution Margin to judge results.

Sort your products into four groups

Place each product by its Gross Profit margin and its sales volume in a normal month. Each group gets a different BFCM role.

High margin Low margin
High volume Protect. Bestsellers that sell anyway. Discount lightly or use a gift with purchase instead. Fix. Popular but thin. Bundle them with high-margin items or raise order value with thresholds.
Low volume Scale. Room to discount. Feature them in BFCM offers and ads to win new customers. Cut. Clear them with a deep discount if stock is tied up, or leave them out of BFCM.

This matrix replaces a sitewide discount with a plan: deep offers where margin allows, protection where it does not.

Step 3: Calculate your breakeven discount and breakeven ROAS

These two numbers set the limits for your BFCM offers and ads. Work them out for every product you plan to discount.

Breakeven discount

The breakeven discount is the deepest discount a product can take before each order stops making money, after the ad cost you expect to pay for it.

Breakeven discount = (Price − costs per order − expected ad cost per order) ÷ Price

Costs per order are product cost plus fulfillment, shipping and payment fees. For the $80 product with $40 in costs and an expected ad cost of $15 per order: ($80 − $40 − $15) ÷ $80 = 31%. At 31% off, the order makes zero profit.

Your discount ceiling sits below that, so each order still earns something. Subtract the profit you want to keep per order as well. Keeping $10 per order gives ($80 − $40 − $15 − $10) ÷ $80 = 19%.

Breakeven ROAS

Breakeven ROAS is the return on ad spend a product needs just to cover its costs.

Breakeven ROAS = Price after discount ÷ Gross Profit per order after discount

At full price, the $80 product needs a ROAS of 2.0 ($80 ÷ $40). At 25% off, it needs 3.0 ($60 ÷ $20). Any ad running below that ROAS loses money on every sale. More detail in How to Calculate Breakeven ROAS.

Set a discount ceiling for each product

Example, using three of the product groups from Step 2:

Product (group) Price Costs per order Expected ad cost per order Breakeven discount Discount ceiling (keep $5 to $10 per order)
Bestseller (Protect) $80 $40 $15 31% 19%
Under-promoted product (Scale) $60 $18 $15 45% 37%
Popular low-margin product (Fix) $40 $30 $10 0% No discount: bundle it instead

Costs in this table are fixed for simplicity. In practice, payment fees fall slightly as the price drops, so recalculate with your real fee rates.

A free calculator for this is coming soon: Black Friday Discount Profit Calculator.

Step 4: Set MER and aMER targets before you spend

Breakeven ROAS works product by product. MER and aMER work at store level, and they are the numbers to trust during BFCM, when every ad platform claims credit for the same sales.

MER: is total ad spend paying off?

MER (Marketing Efficiency Ratio) is total store revenue divided by total ad spend, across every channel.

Breakeven MER = 1 ÷ Gross Profit margin

Target MER = 1 ÷ (Gross Profit margin − target Contribution Margin)

Say your BFCM offers leave a blended Gross Profit margin of 35%. Your breakeven MER is 1 ÷ 0.35 = 2.9. If you want to keep a 10% Contribution Margin, your target MER is 1 ÷ (0.35 − 0.10) = 4.0. Below 2.9, every extra ad dollar loses money.

Work out your Gross Profit margin at your planned BFCM prices, not your normal ones. Discounts lower the margin, which raises the MER you need. More in What Is MER?

aMER: are ads winning new customers profitably?

aMER (Acquisition MER) is revenue from new customers divided by total ad spend. It separates growth from sales you would have made anyway, because returning customers often buy during BFCM whether or not you advertise.

Set your aMER target from what a new customer is worth. If BFCM customers usually buy again at full price, a lower aMER can still pay off over 90 days. If they rarely return, your aMER needs to cover the full cost on the first order. Step 5 shows how to check this. More in What Is aMER?

Why platform ROAS is not enough

During BFCM, a shopper might see a Meta ad, search on Google, click an email and then buy. Meta, Google and your email tool can each count that order. Add up the sales each platform reports and you can get more than your store actually made. MER is calculated from real orders, so it cannot be inflated this way.

Step 5: Review last year's BFCM at profit level

Last year's BFCM is your best guide to this year's, as long as you judge it by profit. Revenue reports will tell you it went well. These three checks tell you what to repeat.

Which offers and campaigns actually made money

List each BFCM offer and campaign from last year with its revenue, discount cost, ad spend and Contribution Margin. Look for offers that drove volume but little profit, and campaigns whose platform-reported ROAS looked strong while MER for the period was weak.

Repeat what earned Contribution Margin. Drop or rework what only earned revenue.

Return rate by product after the holidays

Check returns on BFCM orders through January, by product. A product with a high BFCM return rate made less profit than the December report showed. Lower its discount ceiling this year, or take it out of BFCM ads.

Did BFCM customers come back?

Compare customers first acquired during last year's BFCM with customers acquired in a normal month:

Check BFCM customers Normal-month customers
Bought again within 30 days
Bought again within 60 days
Bought again within 90 days
Second order at full price
Average order value on second order

If BFCM customers come back at full price, BFCM is a good acquisition channel for you, and a lower aMER can be worth it. If they only return for the next sale, size your discounts to pay off on the first order.

No data from last year? Set this report up now so you have it for BFCM 2027.

Step 6: Check profit by country and channel

The same offer can be profitable in one market and lose money in another. Cross-border orders made up 16% of all Shopify BFCM orders in 2025 (Shopify), and shipping, duties and ad costs vary widely by country.

By country, compare Gross Profit margin and Contribution Margin for each market you sell to. A country with high revenue but high shipping costs or ad costs may need a smaller discount, a higher free-shipping threshold or no BFCM ads at all. Flag any market where margin falls below your threshold before you set offers.

By channel, compare Contribution Margin for your online store, marketplaces and any wholesale or retail channels. Marketplace fees and their own BFCM promotions can make the same discount far more expensive there than on your own site.

The question for each market and channel is the same: after this discount and this ad spend, does an order still make money?

Step 7: Plan inventory from profit, not just sell-through

Stock planning usually starts from last year's units sold. Start from profit instead, using your four product groups from Step 2.

  • Protect and Scale products: stock deeper. Running out of a high-margin product on Black Friday is the most expensive mistake of the weekend, because those are the orders that pay for everything else.
  • Fix products: stock to normal demand. Their job is to sit in bundles with higher-margin items, not to carry the sale.
  • Cut products: plan to clear what you have rather than reorder. Leftover stock bought for a sale that did not happen ties up cash into January.

Two more checks before you finalize orders:

  1. Lead times. Confirm restock dates for Protect and Scale products before you commit to offers on them.
  2. Channel sync. If you sell in more than one place, make sure inventory syncs across channels, so a sellout on one does not cause cancelled orders on another.

What to monitor during BFCM

During the sale, you compare live numbers with the limits you set in Steps 1 to 4. Check these every morning, and every few hours around the Black Friday peak:

Check Compare against Act when
MER Your target and breakeven MER MER drops toward breakeven: cut the weakest campaigns
Profit by campaign Contribution Margin per campaign A campaign is below breakeven ROAS for a full day: pause it
Profit by product Your discount ceilings A product sells mostly at a loss: lower its ad spend or end its offer
Conversion rate Your baseline A sudden drop: check checkout, discount codes and site speed first
Stock on Protect and Scale products Expected BFCM demand Running low: move ad spend to products with stock

One rule covers all of them: act on profit, not revenue. Revenue will climb all weekend whatever you do. Profit shows which offers and ads to cut while there is still time.

For a ready-made view of these numbers, see How to Build a Shopify BFCM Profit Dashboard.

What to measure after BFCM

The real BFCM result arrives in January, not on Cyber Monday. Wait until holiday returns come in, then measure:

  1. Season profit vs baseline. Contribution Margin for October to December, compared with last year or your normal weeks. This captures the pre-sale dip and the full-price sales BFCM pulled forward.
  2. Profit after returns, by product. Which products kept their profit and which gave it back.
  3. Platform-reported sales vs real sales. The gap between what ad platforms claimed and what your store recorded.
  4. Your BFCM customer cohort. Repeat purchase rate at 30, 60 and 90 days, and whether those repeat orders were at full price.

Write down what to repeat and what to drop. That note becomes Step 5 for BFCM 2027.

How Bloom helps you plan BFCM around profit

Every step above needs the same thing: profit data that includes all your costs, broken down by product, order, campaign and country. Bloom is a Shopify-native profit analytics app built for exactly that.

  • Steps 1 and 2: Bloom shows overall business profit, product-level margins and order-level profit, so your baseline and product groups come from real numbers.
  • Steps 3 and 4: with product costs, fulfillment, fees and ad spend in one place, Gross Profit and Contribution Margin per product are ready for your breakeven math.
  • Step 5: marketing attribution shows real sales by campaign, not the conversions each ad platform estimates.
  • Step 6: Country Profits shows Gross Profit and Profit Margin by country, and flags markets that fall below your margin threshold.
  • During BFCM: Bloom Pulse gives you instant daily highlights on your store's numbers, so the morning profit check takes minutes.

Plan BFCM Around What You'll KeepInstall Bloom on Shopify

Frequently asked questions

What metrics should I track for Black Friday on Shopify?

Start with profit metrics you set before the sale: Gross Profit by product, breakeven discount, breakeven ROAS and a MER target. During BFCM, track MER, profit by campaign and product, conversion rate and stock. After BFCM, measure Contribution Margin after returns and the repeat purchase rate of BFCM customers.

How do I calculate breakeven ROAS for BFCM?

Divide the discounted price by the Gross Profit per order at that price. A product that sells for $60 after a discount and leaves $20 of Gross Profit needs a ROAS of 3.0 to break even.

How much can I discount and still make a profit?

Use this formula: (price − costs per order − expected ad cost per order) ÷ price. That gives your breakeven discount. Set your actual discount below it so each order keeps some profit, and calculate it for each product rather than sitewide.

What is a good MER for BFCM?

It depends on your margins. Your breakeven MER is 1 divided by your Gross Profit margin at BFCM prices. To keep a profit, divide 1 by your Gross Profit margin minus the Contribution Margin you want to keep. With a 35% Gross Profit margin and a 10% profit goal, that is a MER of 4.0.

How do I know if BFCM customers are worth acquiring?

Compare last year's BFCM customers with customers acquired in a normal month. If they buy again at full price within 90 days at a similar rate, BFCM is a good acquisition channel. If they only come back for sales, size your discounts to pay off on the first order.

Should I track revenue or profit during BFCM?

Track profit. Revenue rises all weekend whatever you do, so it cannot tell you which offers or ads to cut. Profit by product and campaign can, while there is still time to act.